There’s a small grain of truth, some aged cheeses contain SPERMIDINE, a compound shown to promote autophagy in cells and animal models but there’s NO GOOD SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE eating “¼ cup of this BLUE cheese” will double your autophagy in HUMANS right away, nor that you can reliably trigger a 2× increase without OTHER FACTORS like fasting.
Spermidine activates autophagy in lab studies. Multiple papers show spermidine induces autophagy and extends lifespan in yeast, worms, flies and some mammalian cell/animal models. That’s solid preclinical science.
Aged cheeses are a real dietary source of spermidine. Mature cheddars, parmesan, gouda, etc., have measurable spermidine (amounts vary by type and ageing). But milligram per 100g is modest and variable across cheeses.
Human data are messy and associative. Population studies link higher dietary spermidine with lower mortality and better outcomes, but that’s correlation, not proof that a serving of cheese acutely doubles autophagy in people.
Clinical trials of spermidine supplements show mixed/limited effects on circulating polyamines and biomarkers so far.
Dose and bioavailability also matter. Food spermidine can be metabolized before it reaches circulation (it can convert to spermine, etc.), and the amounts required to reproduce the effects seen in lab animals or cell cultures are not the same as “eat some cheese and boom, autophagy ×2.”
BOTTOM LINE: WHAT TO BELIEVE AND WHAT TO DO
Believe: Spermidine is a bona fide autophagy inducer in model systems, and aged cheese is a dietary source.
Don’t believe: the specific viral-style claim that a small serving of cheese gives you an immediate 2× autophagy boost comparable to fasting. There’s no solid human evidence for that dramatic, immediate effect.
PRACTICAL, EVIDENCE-MINDED moves if you want to support autophagy and healthy aging:
Intermittent fasting / caloric restriction, exercise, and certain compounds (e.g., spermidine in trials) are the better-supported levers.
FASTING + EXERCISE are consistently reproducible ways to stimulate autophagy.
Add spermidine-rich foods moderately: natto, mature cheeses, mushrooms, green peas, wheat germ, soy products.
Don’t binge cheese to chase a lab number you’ll get sodium and calories instead.
If considering spermidine supplements, be cautious: human trials are ongoing and results are mixed; talk with a clinician if you have health conditions or take meds.
WHY THE CLAIM “1/4 CUP CHEESE INCREASES AUTOPHAGY 2X’ IS ALMOST CERTAINLY FALSE
1) No scientific study (randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial) MEASURING the doubling effect.
There is NO peer-reviewed research that tests “1/4 cups of cheese” and measures autophagy markers (like LC3, p62, etc.) doubling, in humans or animals, without fasting.
2) Quantity check: The spermidine content of aged cheese is highly variable but usually around 2–15 mg/kg. A quarter cup of cheese (say 30g) would give you at most a few tenths of a milligram of spermidine.
Studies that see measurable effects on autophagy in humans usually involve ~1 mg/day or MORE, often from spermidine SUPPLEMENTS or high-spermidine foods like WHEAT GERM.
Eating too much blue cheese would also mean huge amount of calories, protein, fat, SALT and etc.
That alone would trigger many other metabolic effects likely bad ones (e.g. huge insulin responses, lipid load) which would inhibit autophagy in many contexts.
3) Autophagy is inhibited by nutrient abundance: Foods high in amino acids (especially leucine), insulin-stimulating foods, and caloric plenty tend to suppress autophagy (via mTOR activation).
Cheese is rich in protein, amino acids, etc., which generally downregulate autophagy signaling pathways if consumed in large amounts.
4) Context matters: Whether autophagy is increased depends on many variables the metabolic state (fasting vs fed), type of tissue (liver, skeletal muscle, neurons, etc.), stress / exercise, genetic factors, even age.
5) Protein & mTOR activation: Cheese is rich in protein, especially leucine, which strongly activates the mTOR pathway. mTOR is the biochemical “off switch” for autophagy.
So after eating cheese, the default expectation is less autophagy, not more.
6) Doubling? Marketing spin: Even if the cheese contributed some spermidine, jumping to “2× autophagy” is an exaggeration.
Human autophagy isn’t measured in neat multipliers in living people, researchers infer it from biomarkers, and changes are subtle, not dramatic like flipping a switch.
7) Possible confusion with spermidine: Some aged cheeses (like cheddar, parmesan, gouda) contain spermidine, a polyamine found in fermented/aged foods.
Spermidine has been shown in studies (mostly cell culture, some animal, early human) to stimulate autophagy. That’s the most likely source of this claim.
Don’t believe what you watch on Tiktok unless there’s brand-new unpublished data, the idea that a specific cheese (blue cheese) will double autophagy without fasting is not supported by current science. Could be marketing hype, misinterpretation, or ignorance.
SCIENTIFIC REFERENCES:
1) Induction of autophagy by spermidine promotes longevity, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19801973/
2) Polyamines in foods: development of a food database – PMC, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3022763/
3) The association of dietary spermidine with all-cause mortality and CVD mortality: The U.S. National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 2003 to 2014, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9554131/
4) High-Dose Spermidine Supplementation Does Not Increase Spermidine Levels in Blood Plasma and Saliva of Healthy Adults: A Randomized Placebo-Controlled Pharmacokinetic and Metabolomic Study, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10143675/
5) Macroautophagy- The key ingredient to a healthy diet?, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3135626/
6) Metabolic Responses to Spermidine Supplementation, https://www.clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT05459961
No comments:
Post a Comment